diff --git a/.dockerignore b/.dockerignore index 1f05501..c5d9e9b 100644 --- a/.dockerignore +++ b/.dockerignore @@ -52,6 +52,11 @@ README* CHANGELOG* TODO* +# …except README.md: pyproject.toml declares `readme = "README.md"`, so the +# build backend needs it present to install the project. Excluding it made +# `uv sync` in the Dockerfiles die with "Readme file does not exist". +!README.md + # Development and build tools Makefile docker-compose*.yml diff --git a/Dockerfile b/Dockerfile index a03fd56..dbc52b6 100644 --- a/Dockerfile +++ b/Dockerfile @@ -16,23 +16,39 @@ RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends \ curl \ && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/* -# Install uv -COPY --from=ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:latest /uv /uvx /bin/ +# Install uv from PyPI at a pinned version. +# +# This used to be `COPY --from=ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:latest`, which pulled +# an unpinned tag: image contents changed under you between builds, and a +# breaking uv release could break the build with no diff to show for it. +# PyPI is already required by every other layer here, so sourcing uv from +# it also drops a second registry from the build's dependency set. +ARG UV_VERSION=0.8.17 +RUN pip install --no-cache-dir "uv==${UV_VERSION}" # Set working directory WORKDIR /app -# Copy dependency files first for cache efficiency -COPY pyproject.toml uv.lock ./ +# Copy dependency files first for cache efficiency. +# README.md is required: pyproject.toml declares it as the project readme, +# so the build backend fails without it when uv installs the project below. +COPY pyproject.toml uv.lock README.md ./ # Install dependencies (without the project itself) +# Extras matter here: a bare `uv sync` installs only the core dependencies, so +# the image shipped without sqlalchemy, langgraph, prometheus-client or pyjwt — +# /metrics served nothing, DATABASE_URL failed with "No module named +# 'sqlalchemy'", and JWT auth could not be enabled at all. `all` restores those +# and matches what `agentomatic deploy` builds. `db-postgres` is named +# separately because `all` deliberately carries only the SQLite driver, and +# this image is a deployment: the compose stack beside it offers Postgres. RUN --mount=type=cache,target=/root/.cache/uv \ - uv sync --frozen --no-install-project --no-dev + uv sync --frozen --no-install-project --no-dev --extra all --extra db-postgres # Copy source code and install the project COPY src/ ./src/ RUN --mount=type=cache,target=/root/.cache/uv \ - uv sync --frozen --no-dev + uv sync --frozen --no-dev --extra all --extra db-postgres # Production stage FROM python:3.12-slim diff --git a/Dockerfile.distroless b/Dockerfile.distroless index abc22d7..8976475 100644 --- a/Dockerfile.distroless +++ b/Dockerfile.distroless @@ -3,13 +3,17 @@ # built-in ``nonroot`` account (numeric UID 65532) so images honour # Kubernetes ``runAsNonRoot`` admission policies out of the box. -# Build stage -FROM python:3.12-slim AS builder +# ---- Build stage ------------------------------------------------------------ +# Python 3.11 on purpose: ``distroless/python3-debian12`` ships Debian 12's +# Python 3.11, and dependencies must be built for the interpreter that will +# actually import them. Building on 3.12 produced an image that could not start +# at all — the venv's ``bin/python`` symlinked to the builder's 3.12 binary, +# which does not exist in the runtime stage, so the ENTRYPOINT was a dangling +# symlink; and even resolved, cp312 wheels cannot be imported under 3.11. +FROM python:3.11-slim AS builder -# Set environment variables ENV PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 \ PYTHONUNBUFFERED=1 \ - UV_COMPILE_BYTECODE=1 \ UV_LINK_MODE=copy # Install system dependencies @@ -18,40 +22,40 @@ RUN apt-get update && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends \ curl \ && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/* -# Install uv -COPY --from=ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:latest /uv /uvx /bin/ +# Install uv from PyPI at a pinned version. An unpinned `uv:latest` image made +# builds irreproducible, and PyPI is already required by every other layer. +ARG UV_VERSION=0.8.17 +RUN pip install --no-cache-dir "uv==${UV_VERSION}" -# Set working directory WORKDIR /app -# Copy dependency files -COPY pyproject.toml uv.lock ./ - -# Install dependencies -RUN --mount=type=cache,target=/root/.cache/uv \ - uv sync --frozen --no-install-project --no-dev - -# Copy source code and install +# README.md is required: pyproject.toml declares it as the project readme, so +# installing the project below fails without it. +COPY pyproject.toml uv.lock README.md ./ COPY src/ ./src/ -RUN --mount=type=cache,target=/root/.cache/uv \ - uv sync --frozen --no-dev -# Ensure the runtime user (uid 65532 / nonroot) can read the venv and sources -RUN chown -R 65532:65532 /app +# ``--target`` instead of a virtualenv: the runtime stage runs the distroless +# image's own interpreter, which cannot use a venv built around a different +# Python binary. A plain directory on ``PYTHONPATH`` works with any 3.11. +# +# Extras matter here: a bare install ships core dependencies only, leaving the +# image without sqlalchemy, langgraph, prometheus-client or pyjwt — /metrics +# served nothing, DATABASE_URL failed with "No module named 'sqlalchemy'", and +# JWT auth could not be enabled. ``db-postgres`` is named separately because +# ``all`` deliberately carries only the SQLite driver. +RUN --mount=type=cache,target=/root/.cache/uv \ + uv pip install --target=/app/deps ".[all,db-postgres]" -# Production stage — distroless, non-root by default +# ---- Runtime stage ---------------------------------------------------------- FROM gcr.io/distroless/python3-debian12:nonroot -# Set environment variables ENV PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 \ PYTHONUNBUFFERED=1 \ - PATH="/app/.venv/bin:$PATH" \ - VIRTUAL_ENV="/app/.venv" + PYTHONPATH="/app/deps" WORKDIR /app -# Copy virtual environment and application from builder -COPY --from=builder --chown=65532:65532 /app/.venv /app/.venv +COPY --from=builder --chown=65532:65532 /app/deps /app/deps COPY --from=builder --chown=65532:65532 /app/src /app/src COPY --from=builder --chown=65532:65532 /app/pyproject.toml /app/ @@ -59,17 +63,16 @@ COPY --from=builder --chown=65532:65532 /app/pyproject.toml /app/ # have to introspect the base image at admit-time. USER 65532:65532 -# Expose port EXPOSE 8000 -# Distroless has no shell, but it can execute binaries directly. We -# invoke the ``agentomatic`` console script (installed by uv into -# ``/app/.venv/bin``) via the venv Python so both the plain and -# distroless images boot through the same ``agentomatic run`` entrypoint. -ENTRYPOINT ["/app/.venv/bin/python", "/app/.venv/bin/agentomatic"] +# Distroless has no shell, so run the CLI as a module through the base image's +# own interpreter; dependencies come from PYTHONPATH. Invoking the console +# script directly would go through its shebang, which points at the builder's +# interpreter and is not present here. +ENTRYPOINT ["/usr/bin/python3", "-m", "agentomatic.cli.commands"] CMD ["run", "--agents-dir", "agents", "--host", "0.0.0.0", "--port", "8000"] -# No shell and no curl in this image — hit /health with the venv Python +# No shell and no curl in this image — hit /health with the base interpreter # instead (exec form, so no shell is needed to run this CMD either). HEALTHCHECK --interval=30s --timeout=10s --start-period=30s --retries=3 \ - CMD ["/app/.venv/bin/python", "-c", "import urllib.request as u; u.urlopen('http://localhost:8000/health', timeout=5)"] + CMD ["/usr/bin/python3", "-c", "import urllib.request as u; u.urlopen('http://localhost:8000/health', timeout=5)"] diff --git a/docker-compose.yml b/docker-compose.yml index ddfabc7..5738603 100644 --- a/docker-compose.yml +++ b/docker-compose.yml @@ -1,52 +1,81 @@ +# ============================================================================= +# Agentomatic — local production-shaped stack +# +# docker compose up --build # platform on http://localhost:8000 +# docker compose --profile db up -d # …with Postgres-backed persistence +# +# One platform process serves every agent it discovers under ./agents — that +# is the point of the product, so there is no per-agent service here. Features +# are driven entirely by AGENTOMATIC_* env vars, exactly as in the image that +# `agentomatic deploy` generates, so what you exercise locally is what ships. +# ============================================================================= + services: - # Alpha Agent - alpha-agent: - build: . - container_name: alpha-agent + platform: + build: + context: . + dockerfile: Dockerfile + image: agentomatic:latest + container_name: agentomatic-platform + restart: unless-stopped ports: - - "8001:8000" + - "${AGENTOMATIC_PORT:-8000}:8000" environment: - - AGENT_NAME=alpha - - PORT=8000 - - OPENAI_API_KEY=${OPENAI_API_KEY} - - ANTHROPIC_API_KEY=${ANTHROPIC_API_KEY} - command: ["agentomatic", "run", "--agents-dir", "agents", "--host", "0.0.0.0", "--port", "8000"] + AGENTOMATIC_TITLE: "${AGENTOMATIC_TITLE:-Agentomatic Platform}" + AGENTOMATIC_LOG_LEVEL: "${AGENTOMATIC_LOG_LEVEL:-INFO}" + # Studio, docs, health and metrics are on by default. + AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_STUDIO: "${AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_STUDIO:-1}" + AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_METRICS: "${AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_METRICS:-1}" + AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_CONTROL_PLANE: "${AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_CONTROL_PLANE:-1}" + # Opt-in hardening — set these in .env before exposing the port. + AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_AUTH: "${AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_AUTH:-0}" + AGENTOMATIC_API_KEY: "${AGENTOMATIC_API_KEY:-}" + AGENTOMATIC_CONTROL_TOKEN: "${AGENTOMATIC_CONTROL_TOKEN:-}" + AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_RATE_LIMIT: "${AGENTOMATIC_ENABLE_RATE_LIMIT:-0}" + # Durable invocation history. Empty DATABASE_URL keeps it in-memory. + AGENTOMATIC_LOGS_HISTORY: "${AGENTOMATIC_LOGS_HISTORY:-0}" + DATABASE_URL: "${DATABASE_URL:-}" + # Bring your own model provider; nothing vendor-specific is baked in. + OPENAI_API_KEY: "${OPENAI_API_KEY:-}" + ANTHROPIC_API_KEY: "${ANTHROPIC_API_KEY:-}" volumes: - - ./agents:/app/agents - networks: - - agentomatic-network + # Drop agents in and restart — no rebuild needed for iteration. + - ./agents:/app/agents:ro + - agentomatic-data:/app/data + healthcheck: + test: ["CMD", "curl", "-f", "http://localhost:8000/health"] + interval: 30s + timeout: 10s + retries: 3 + start_period: 30s + networks: [agentomatic] - # Beta Agent - beta-agent: - build: . - container_name: beta-agent - ports: - - "8002:8000" + # Enable with: docker compose --profile db up -d + # then point the platform at it by setting, in .env: + # DATABASE_URL=postgresql+asyncpg://agentomatic:agentomatic@db:5432/agentomatic + # AGENTOMATIC_LOGS_HISTORY=1 + db: + profiles: ["db"] + image: postgres:16-alpine + container_name: agentomatic-db + restart: unless-stopped environment: - - AGENT_NAME=beta - - PORT=8000 - - OPENAI_API_KEY=${OPENAI_API_KEY} - - ANTHROPIC_API_KEY=${ANTHROPIC_API_KEY} - command: ["agentomatic", "run", "--agents-dir", "agents", "--host", "0.0.0.0", "--port", "8000"] + POSTGRES_USER: "${POSTGRES_USER:-agentomatic}" + POSTGRES_PASSWORD: "${POSTGRES_PASSWORD:-agentomatic}" + POSTGRES_DB: "${POSTGRES_DB:-agentomatic}" volumes: - - ./agents:/app/agents - networks: - - agentomatic-network + - agentomatic-db:/var/lib/postgresql/data + healthcheck: + test: ["CMD-SHELL", "pg_isready -U ${POSTGRES_USER:-agentomatic}"] + interval: 5s + timeout: 5s + retries: 20 + networks: [agentomatic] - # Nginx reverse proxy - nginx: - image: nginx:alpine - container_name: agentomatic-proxy - ports: - - "80:80" - volumes: - - ./nginx.conf:/etc/nginx/nginx.conf:ro - depends_on: - - alpha-agent - - beta-agent - networks: - - agentomatic-network +volumes: + agentomatic-data: + agentomatic-db: networks: - agentomatic-network: + agentomatic: driver: bridge diff --git a/docs/FRONTEND_API_GUIDE.md b/docs/FRONTEND_API_GUIDE.md index 4b1cf13..b96baf5 100644 --- a/docs/FRONTEND_API_GUIDE.md +++ b/docs/FRONTEND_API_GUIDE.md @@ -213,7 +213,7 @@ the frontend submits work, then **polls** or **streams** progress. **Submit** (returns immediately with `202` and a task record): - Agent: `POST /api/v1/{agent}/invoke/async` (single) · `/invoke/batch` (many) -- Plugin: `POST /api/v1/{plugin}/predict/async` · `/predict/batch` +- Plugin: `POST /api/v1/plugins/{plugin}/predict/async` · `/predict/batch` - Pipeline: `POST /api/v1/pipelines/{name}/run/async` · `/run/batch` - Endpoint: `POST /api/v1/endpoints/{name}{path}/async` · `.../batch` - Ingestor: `POST /api/v1/ingestion/{name}/run/async` · `/run/batch` diff --git a/docs/guide/deployment.md b/docs/guide/deployment.md index 8405b39..14f5fd2 100644 --- a/docs/guide/deployment.md +++ b/docs/guide/deployment.md @@ -53,6 +53,50 @@ Everything above is configured declaratively — agents in folders, connections in `connections.py`, endpoints in `endpoint.py`, and a handful of platform flags. No custom FastAPI wiring is required. +## Project dependencies in the generated image + +`agentomatic deploy` builds with **uv**, pinned via `ARG UV_VERSION` so the +image is reproducible, and installs your project's own dependencies as well +as agentomatic itself. + +Declare what *your* project needs — a vendor LLM driver, a vector client, an +in-house package — in `requirements.txt` next to `main.py`: + +```txt title="requirements.txt" +agentomatic[all]==1.10.0 +# This project's agents talk to a local OpenAI-compatible model server, +# so it needs that client library. +langchain-openai>=0.3 +``` + +The generated Dockerfile installs agentomatic first (at its pinned version) +and your requirements second, so a looser pin in your file cannot downgrade +the framework. + +!!! warning "This is how a provider driver reaches the image" + + The `all` extra deliberately excludes the vendor LLM drivers — `openai`, + `azure`, `vertex` — because the platform is provider-agnostic: you install + the SDK for the backend you actually use. `requirements.txt` is where that + happens. A stack configured for `openai_compatible` (which is what oMLX, + llama.cpp, vLLM and LM Studio all speak) needs `langchain-openai` there, + or the platform will refuse to start rather than answer with a fake model. + +### Reproducible builds with a lockfile + +If your project keeps a `pyproject.toml` and a `uv.lock`, the generated +Dockerfile installs from the lock instead: + +```dockerfile +COPY pyproject.toml uv.lock ./ +RUN uv sync --frozen --no-dev --inexact +``` + +That installs the exact resolved versions the lock pins rather than +re-resolving at build time. Regenerate the lock with `uv lock` whenever you +change a dependency. + + ## 1. Install for production Install only the extras you use. Common production combinations: diff --git a/docs/guide/optimization.md b/docs/guide/optimization.md index 042f544..79e4be8 100644 --- a/docs/guide/optimization.md +++ b/docs/guide/optimization.md @@ -6,6 +6,22 @@ Inspired by Stanford's [DSPy](https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy), the framewor --- +## Seeing the whole loop run + +`scripts/keras_showcase.py` runs `compile() → fit() → evaluate() → save() → +load()` against any OpenAI-compatible endpoint and prints the measured loss +curve, so you can watch the loop move before wiring it to your own agent: + +```bash +export OMLX_BASE_URL=http://127.0.0.1:8000/v1 +export OMLX_API_KEY=whatever +python scripts/keras_showcase.py --model omlx/my-local-model +``` + +Its agent answers correctly only once the prompt contains a token it has to +*discover from its own failures*, so an improvement in the curve is +attributable to the optimizer rather than to model variance. + ## 🏗️ The Optimization Flow The optimization loop coordinates datasets, rewriter LLMs, evaluator LLMs, and scoring metrics to iteratively improve prompt versions: @@ -14,6 +30,44 @@ The optimization loop coordinates datasets, rewriter LLMs, evaluator LLMs, and s --- +## Running the optimization suites without a cloud key + +The live optimization suites drive a real OpenAI-compatible endpoint. Point +them at whatever local model you run — oMLX, llama.cpp, vLLM, LM Studio, +Ollama — and they need no changes: + +```bash +export OMLX_BASE_URL=http://127.0.0.1:8000/v1 +export OMLX_API_KEY=your-key +export AGENTOMATIC_LIVE_MODEL=omlx/your-model + +uv run pytest tests/test_live_omlx_optimize.py \ + tests/test_live_omlx_keras_optimize.py \ + -q --override-ini='addopts=' +``` + +Without such an endpoint these suites **skip entirely**, which leaves the +`omlx/` provider path, the prompt fitter and the whole Keras-style `fit()` +loop unexercised — including in CI. For that case the repo ships a stand-in: + +```bash +uv run python scripts/local_slm_server.py --port 8000 +``` + +`scripts/local_slm_server.py` is a **test double, not a language model**. It +generates nothing; it follows rules. What makes it a valid optimization target +is that answer quality genuinely depends on the system prompt — each directive +a prompt carries makes the response satisfy one more property the metric +rewards, so an optimizer that really searches and selects will climb, and one +that does not will not. It also plays the rewriter (reading the briefing's +failing I/O and expected answers, then folding the missing tokens into a new +prompt) and the judge (returning the exact schema the metric asked for). + +It proves the *machinery* — search, evaluation, selection, early stopping, +checkpointing, config application. It cannot tell you whether a real model +writes good prompts. Use your own model and eval set for that. + + ## ⚡ Quick Start — two tiers (same primitives) Agentomatic exposes **both** a thin one-shot path and a Keras-like staged path. @@ -261,6 +315,18 @@ Agentomatic supports standard matches, LLM judges, and full **DeepEval** validat - **Exact Match** (`exact_match`): Verifies if the agent response matches the expected answer exactly. - **Contains** (`contains`): Verifies if the agent response contains a set of defined target keywords. +!!! note "Matching metrics read the answer, not the whole reference" + An `AgentExample` with a structured `expected_output` is rendered for the + optimizer as a *judge-facing reference* — judge guidance, a rubric, an + `## Expected answer` section, the structured output as JSON. An LLM judge + reads all of it. + + A matching metric compares strings, so it reads only the + `## Expected answer` section. Without that it would be comparing your + agent's response against markdown headers, and every candidate would score + near zero however good it was — `fit()` would report "no improvement" + forever. Plain-string expectations are used exactly as written. + ### 2. LLM-as-a-Judge Metrics - **LLM Judge** (`llm_judge`): Asks an evaluator LLM to grade the response on a scale of 0 to 1 based on custom criteria instructions. - **G-Eval** (`g_eval`): Uses the G-Eval framework protocol to evaluate complex criteria (e.g. coherence, readability) with detailed scoring rubrics. diff --git a/docs/guide/pipelines.md b/docs/guide/pipelines.md index 434f0e0..9f0236e 100644 --- a/docs/guide/pipelines.md +++ b/docs/guide/pipelines.md @@ -303,6 +303,24 @@ steps: `max`, `min`, `sum`, `sorted`, `isinstance`. The `ctx` variable is a `PipelineContext` instance. +!!! danger "A broken condition fails the step — it does not skip it" + A condition that *raises* (a typo, a renamed step, `$.` mapping syntax + where a `ctx` expression belongs) is a defect in the pipeline, not a + routing decision. The step is marked **failed** and the pipeline's + `on_error` policy decides what happens next. + + ```yaml + # ❌ `$.` is mapping syntax — invalid Python, so this step fails. + condition: "$.classify.confidence < 0.7" + + # ✅ A `ctx` expression. + condition: "ctx.get_step_output('classify').get('confidence', 0) < 0.7" + ``` + + `validate()` compiles every condition before a run, so a syntax error + like the first line above is rejected at load time (HTTP 422) rather + than at step three of a long pipeline. + ### Loop Repeat a step until a condition is met or a maximum iteration count is diff --git a/docs/guide/platform-features.md b/docs/guide/platform-features.md index 2f3f33e..25ed32e 100644 --- a/docs/guide/platform-features.md +++ b/docs/guide/platform-features.md @@ -484,10 +484,36 @@ By default the chain advances only on configured triggers (`timeout`, Agentomatic provides **automatic conversation memory** for all deployed agents. When a thread store is configured, every `/chat` and `/invoke` call automatically: 1. **Loads prior conversation history** into the agent's `messages` state -2. **Invokes the agent** with full conversational context +2. **Invokes the agent** with that state 3. **Persists** both user and assistant messages to the store 4. **Summarises** older messages when the conversation grows long +!!! warning "Your agent has to *read* `messages` — loading it is not enough" + The platform fills `state["messages"]` and reports `history_loaded`. + Whether the model ever sees those turns is the agent's decision. An + agent that sends only `current_query` answers every turn as if it were + the first, while the response still says `history_loaded: 12`. + + A conversational agent should pass the turns through: + + ```python + from agentomatic.langchain_adapter import dict_to_messages + from langchain_core.messages import SystemMessage + + def respond(self, state: ChatState) -> ChatState: + # state.messages already ends with the current turn -- do not + # append state.request again, or the model sees it twice. + turns = dict_to_messages( + state.messages if state.messages else {"current_query": state.request} + ) + result = self.llm.invoke([SystemMessage(content=self.prompt), *turns]) + ... + ``` + + The `chatbot` and `langchain` templates ship this wiring. The other + templates take `current_query` alone on purpose: an extraction or + routing agent that dragged in prior turns would be the surprise. + ``` Frontend Agentomatic Store │ │ │ @@ -597,7 +623,7 @@ The response includes all agent output fields plus conversation metadata: | `steps_taken` | Processing steps the agent took | | `context` | Context data returned by agent (RAG docs, search results, etc.) | | `metadata` | Merged metadata (request + agent + prompt_version) | -| `history_loaded` | Number of prior messages loaded into context | +| `history_loaded` | Prior messages **loaded from the store** — not proof the agent sent them to the model (see the warning above) | | `duration_ms` | Processing time in milliseconds | ### Windowing & Summarization diff --git a/docs/guide/verifying-a-deployment.md b/docs/guide/verifying-a-deployment.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..81ff237 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/guide/verifying-a-deployment.md @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +# Verifying a Deployment + +`scripts/e2e_verify.py` drives every surface the platform publishes against a +**running server** and reports pass/fail per group. It is deployment-agnostic: +point it at `agentomatic run`, at `uvicorn main:app`, or at a container built +by `agentomatic deploy`, and it adapts to what that deployment actually has +switched on. + +Use it to answer the question a test suite cannot: *does this container, with +this configuration, behave correctly right now?* + +```bash +python scripts/e2e_verify.py \ + --base-url http://localhost:8000 \ + --agent my_agent --plugin my_plugin --pipeline my_pipeline \ + --endpoint my_endpoint --ingestor my_ingestor \ + --api-key "$AGENTOMATIC_API_KEY" \ + --control-token "$AGENTOMATIC_CONTROL_TOKEN" \ + --expect-auth \ + --json report.json +``` + +The exit code is `0` only when every check passes, so it drops straight into +CI or a post-deploy gate. + +## What it checks + +| Group | Covers | +|---|---| +| `platform` | `/health`, `/ready`, `/readiness`, `/status`, `/api/v1/status`, OpenAPI, Swagger, ReDoc, agent registry | +| `studio` | Every call the bundled Studio React client makes — info, agents, graph, schemas, config, runs, thread state/history, the SSE run stream, and the SPA bundle itself | +| `agent-rest` | `invoke`, `chat`, `invoke/stream` (SSE), `invoke/batch`, health, card, config, prompts, and the full thread lifecycle including fork, messages, summary, lineage, approvals and feedback | +| `a2a` | Agent-to-Agent task submit, poll and cancel | +| `plugins` | Registry, model card, health, `predict`, `predict/batch`, reload | +| `endpoints` | Registry, info, health, call | +| `ingestion` | Both `/api/v1/ingestion` and the `/api/v1/ingestors` alias the Studio bundle uses, plus per-ingestor info and health | +| `pipelines` | Registry, config, validate, visualize, run, and `validate-draft` | +| `pipelines-all` | Runs **every** published pipeline, not just the sampled one, and reports which of the nine step types actually executed | +| `isolation` | Fans out concurrent callers, each carrying a unique marker, and asserts no response or thread ever carries another caller's | +| `tasks` | The task board, `invoke/async` submission, and polling a task to a terminal state | +| `metrics` | Prometheus exposition and the presence of `agentomatic_*` series | +| `rate-limit` | That user routes *are* limited and probes and `/metrics` are *not* | +| `auth` | Anonymous and wrong-credential rejection, valid-credential acceptance, and that every probe path stays public | +| `errors` | Unknown agents, plugins, pipelines, endpoints and tasks return 4xx — never a 500 | +| `control-plane` | Every read route, plus disabling an agent, confirming it stops serving, re-enabling it, and toggling maintenance | + +## Adapting to the deployment + +The harness distinguishes *not configured* from *broken*, so a lean deployment +does not produce false failures: + +- **No Studio** (`--profile minimal`): pass `--no-studio`. +- **No auth**: omit `--expect-auth`; the auth group is skipped. +- **No control plane / no metrics / no rate limiting**: detected from the + response and reported as skipped. +- **No store**: thread and optimization-run routes answer `400`; the harness + reports them skipped and names the variables that would enable them + (`DATABASE_URL`, `AGENTOMATIC_LOGS_HISTORY`). + +Rate limiting is handled rather than worked around: the harness is itself a +burst of traffic from one IP, so it honours `Retry-After` and retries — except +where a `429` is the property under test. + +## Durability: does the data outlive the container? + +Every check above runs against one live process, and a store that quietly fell +back to a file inside the container passes all of them — it writes, it reads +back, and only a restart tells the two apart. `durability_verify.py` splits the +proof across a restart so the difference shows: + +```bash +python scripts/durability_verify.py write \ + --base-url http://localhost:8000 --api-key "$KEY" --agent my_chatbot + +# Replace the deployment: destroy the container and start a new one from the +# same image against the same database. A restart that keeps the writable +# layer proves nothing. +docker rm -f my-agent && docker run -d --name my-agent … my-image + +python scripts/durability_verify.py verify \ + --base-url http://localhost:8000 --api-key "$KEY" --agent my_chatbot +``` + +The `verify` phase reads the thread back, checks each message survived, and +appends one more to confirm the new process can *continue* the conversation +rather than merely read it. + +!!! tip "Watch the boot log for a store you did not choose" + Two things can silently redirect the store away from `DATABASE_URL`: a + MEMORY-purpose connection (which outranks it, and says so with a warning + naming both), and no configuration at all (which falls back to a local + file). Both look identical until the container is replaced. + +## What it does not cover + +- **Model quality.** Agents are exercised for wiring, not for answer quality. + An agent whose LLM is unreachable still passes if it degrades as designed; + use `agentomatic optimize` and your own eval set for quality. +- **Your business logic.** The harness verifies the contract the platform + publishes. Correctness of what your nodes compute is yours to test — see + [Testing Your Agents](testing.md). +- **Load and soak behaviour.** It is a correctness check, not a benchmark. diff --git a/mkdocs.yml b/mkdocs.yml index b8b6f83..47f5ec8 100644 --- a/mkdocs.yml +++ b/mkdocs.yml @@ -133,6 +133,7 @@ nav: - Testing Your Agents: guide/testing.md - Advanced: - Production Deployment: guide/deployment.md + - Verifying a Deployment: guide/verifying-a-deployment.md - Platform Features: guide/platform-features.md - Custom Endpoints: guide/endpoints.md - Tasks & Execution Modes: guide/tasks.md diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_12905a65554d.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_12905a65554d.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6114525 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_12905a65554d.json @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "12905a65554d", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.2867142857142857, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 0 targeting: completeness — ensure answers cover all parts of the question. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 1 targeting: factual grounding — ensure answers are accurate and evidence-based. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 2 targeting: format compliance — ensure answers follow the requested structure. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.42, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "gepa_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_12905a65554d", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.2867, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_142c287799f8.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_142c287799f8.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d0b330c --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_142c287799f8.json @@ -0,0 +1,385 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "142c287799f8", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 1.0009999999999997, + 1.0009999999999997 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [ + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='Which teams need to be unblocked this week?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What is the budget for Q3?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers" + ], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response contains all required markers" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "baseline_holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'Judge', 'OPT', 'banana', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'Judge', 'OPT', 'banana', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Baseline already saturated at 1.0010. The fit metric is too easy (or the dataset is trivial) — prompt candidates cannot show improvement. Harden the metric (content overlap / must_include / judge rubric) and expand demos.", + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.59, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_142c287799f8", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 1.001, + "projected_score": 1.001 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_16acabe00699.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_16acabe00699.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a24b7aa --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_16acabe00699.json @@ -0,0 +1,385 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "16acabe00699", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 1.0009999999999997, + 1.0009999999999997 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [ + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='Which teams need to be unblocked this week?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What is the budget for Q3?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers" + ], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response contains all required markers" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "baseline_holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.45}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.45}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.45}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Baseline already saturated at 1.0010. The fit metric is too easy (or the dataset is trivial) — prompt candidates cannot show improvement. Harden the metric (content overlap / must_include / judge rubric) and expand demos.", + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.72, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_16acabe00699", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 1.001, + "projected_score": 1.001 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_1ae10da0d0e0.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_1ae10da0d0e0.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d1d2424 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_1ae10da0d0e0.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "1ae10da0d0e0", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "rewrite_000", + "source": "rewrite", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Full prompt rewrite at iteration 0 (3 pass(es): pass1_draft chars=452 style=slm, pass2_critique chars=326, pass3_revise chars=452). Analysed 6 failures (avg score 0.144) and 6 successes. Context: 1 rounds history, baseline=0.144, current=0.144.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.37, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "rewrite", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_1ae10da0d0e0", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_23c74d4ea257.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_23c74d4ea257.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..003d0f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_23c74d4ea257.json @@ -0,0 +1,399 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "23c74d4ea257", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.1428571428571428, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.5724285714285714 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperature must be <= 0.3); response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "mipro_000_03", + "train_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "system_prompt": { + "param_name": "system_prompt", + "old_value": "[142 chars]", + "new_value": "[132 chars]", + "reason": "System prompt revised (142 → 132 chars)" + }, + "few_shot_examples": { + "param_name": "few_shot_examples", + "old_value": 4, + "new_value": 4, + "reason": "Few-shot examples changed (4 → 4)" + }, + "model_params.temperature": { + "param_name": "model_params.temperature", + "old_value": 0.6, + "new_value": 0.15, + "reason": "Model param 'temperature': 0.6 → 0.15" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana" + }, + { + "query": "List the next steps for the delivery plan.", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to List the next steps for the delivery plan. banana" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana" + }, + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.6 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.02}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.02}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.02}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.5724, holdout=0.5724, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.5724, holdout=0.5724, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.5724, holdout=0.5724, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "System prompt revised (142 → 132 chars)", + "Few-shot examples changed (4 → 4)", + "Model param 'temperature': 0.6 → 0.15" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.66, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_23c74d4ea257", + "confidence": "high", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.5724 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_28f28abcee98.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_28f28abcee98.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2e042d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_28f28abcee98.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "28f28abcee98", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "rewrite_000", + "source": "rewrite", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Full prompt rewrite at iteration 0 (3 pass(es): pass1_draft chars=452 style=slm, pass2_critique chars=326, pass3_revise chars=452). Analysed 6 failures (avg score 0.144) and 6 successes. Context: 1 rounds history, baseline=0.144, current=0.144.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.35, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "rewrite", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_28f28abcee98", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_296d3b2b6cf1.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_296d3b2b6cf1.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0af8950 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_296d3b2b6cf1.json @@ -0,0 +1,412 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "296d3b2b6cf1", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714282, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "mipro_000_03", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "system_prompt": { + "param_name": "system_prompt", + "old_value": "[136 chars]", + "new_value": "[142 chars]", + "reason": "System prompt revised (136 → 142 chars)" + }, + "few_shot_examples": { + "param_name": "few_shot_examples", + "old_value": 4, + "new_value": 4, + "reason": "Few-shot examples changed (4 → 4)" + }, + "model_params.temperature": { + "param_name": "model_params.temperature", + "old_value": 0.5, + "new_value": 0.6, + "reason": "Model param 'temperature': 0.5 → 0.6" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana" + }, + { + "query": "List the next steps for the delivery plan.", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to List the next steps for the delivery plan. banana" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana" + }, + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.6 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What happened at the steering committee?" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.5 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.7}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.2867, holdout=0.2867, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.2867, holdout=0.2867, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.2867, holdout=0.2867, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "System prompt revised (136 → 142 chars)", + "Few-shot examples changed (4 → 4)", + "Model param 'temperature': 0.5 → 0.6" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.62, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_296d3b2b6cf1", + "confidence": "high", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.6 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_2be78907a291.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_2be78907a291.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e7fbd49 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_2be78907a291.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "2be78907a291", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "rewrite_000", + "source": "rewrite", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Full prompt rewrite at iteration 0 (3 pass(es): pass1_draft chars=452 style=slm, pass2_critique chars=326, pass3_revise chars=452). Analysed 6 failures (avg score 0.144) and 6 successes. Context: 1 rounds history, baseline=0.144, current=0.144.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.5, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "rewrite", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_2be78907a291", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_3d1f73e32b77.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_3d1f73e32b77.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1571f03 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_3d1f73e32b77.json @@ -0,0 +1,183 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "3d1f73e32b77", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_0", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 0): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_1", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 1): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_2", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 2): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.17, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_3d1f73e32b77", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_46c20a9af339.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_46c20a9af339.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4906b2d --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_46c20a9af339.json @@ -0,0 +1,183 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "46c20a9af339", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_0", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 0): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_1", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 1): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_2", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 2): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.12, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_46c20a9af339", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_538677bc709e.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_538677bc709e.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2ecded8 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_538677bc709e.json @@ -0,0 +1,228 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "538677bc709e", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.4295714285714286 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.4295714285714286, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.3", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.25", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.35", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.5", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.2", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.45", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.7", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.1", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.13, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_538677bc709e", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.4296 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_58f5a7c0ef7c.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_58f5a7c0ef7c.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..276b128 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_58f5a7c0ef7c.json @@ -0,0 +1,183 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "58f5a7c0ef7c", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_0", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 0): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_1", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 1): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_2", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 2): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.11, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_58f5a7c0ef7c", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_5a5f2b0a2324.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_5a5f2b0a2324.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9d5a983 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_5a5f2b0a2324.json @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "5a5f2b0a2324", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.2867142857142857, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 0 targeting: completeness — ensure answers cover all parts of the question. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 1 targeting: factual grounding — ensure answers are accurate and evidence-based. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 2 targeting: format compliance — ensure answers follow the requested structure. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.33, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "gepa_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_5a5f2b0a2324", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.2867, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_5e91ff17f6cc.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_5e91ff17f6cc.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..597c915 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_5e91ff17f6cc.json @@ -0,0 +1,385 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "5e91ff17f6cc", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 1.0009999999999997, + 1.0009999999999997 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [ + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='Which teams need to be unblocked this week?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What is the budget for Q3?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers" + ], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response contains all required markers" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "baseline_holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.4}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.4}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.4}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.15}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Baseline already saturated at 1.0010. The fit metric is too easy (or the dataset is trivial) — prompt candidates cannot show improvement. Harden the metric (content overlap / must_include / judge rubric) and expand demos.", + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.76, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_5e91ff17f6cc", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 1.001, + "projected_score": 1.001 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_6a68ffeb6239.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_6a68ffeb6239.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dce6d28 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_6a68ffeb6239.json @@ -0,0 +1,202 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "6a68ffeb6239", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.001, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "tips_000", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.001, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "system_prompt": { + "param_name": "system_prompt", + "old_value": "[31 chars]", + "new_value": "[347 chars]", + "reason": "System prompt revised (31 → 347 chars)" + }, + "few_shot_examples": { + "param_name": "few_shot_examples", + "old_value": 0, + "new_value": 3, + "reason": "Few-shot examples changed (0 → 3)" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "rewrite_000", + "source": "rewrite", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Full prompt rewrite at iteration 0 (3 pass(es): pass1_draft chars=136 style=slm, pass2_critique chars=326, pass3_revise chars=136). Analysed 6 failures (avg score 0.001) and 6 successes. Context: 1 rounds history, baseline=0.001, current=0.001.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "tips_000", + "source": "expected_tips", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Appended expected-grounding tips from dataset at iteration 0.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "tips_000", + "source": "expected_tips", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete" + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "rewrite_000", + "source": "rewrite", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "System prompt revised (31 → 347 chars)", + "Few-shot examples changed (0 → 3)" + ], + "duration_seconds": 1.41, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "rewrite", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_6a68ffeb6239", + "confidence": "high", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_736d05749772.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_736d05749772.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7768016 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_736d05749772.json @@ -0,0 +1,183 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "736d05749772", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_0", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 0): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_1", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 1): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_2", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 2): 4 examples, avg_score=0.144, diversity=1.000, combined=0.401", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.19, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_736d05749772", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_7af1cc2a1511.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_7af1cc2a1511.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0f50a0c --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_7af1cc2a1511.json @@ -0,0 +1,230 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "7af1cc2a1511", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.001, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "fewshot_000_0", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.001, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "few_shot_examples": { + "param_name": "few_shot_examples", + "old_value": 0, + "new_value": 4, + "reason": "Few-shot examples changed (0 → 4)" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_0", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 0): 4 examples, avg_score=0.001, diversity=1.000, combined=0.301", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_1", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 1): 4 examples, avg_score=0.001, diversity=1.000, combined=0.301", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_2", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Few-shot bootstrap (rank 2): 4 examples, avg_score=0.001, diversity=1.000, combined=0.301", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_0", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_1", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "fewshot_000_2", + "source": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Few-shot examples changed (0 → 4)" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.15, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_7af1cc2a1511", + "confidence": "high", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_7d022a054e67.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_7d022a054e67.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6268be3 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_7d022a054e67.json @@ -0,0 +1,327 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "7d022a054e67", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.8581428571428571, + "baseline_score": 0.8581428571428571, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.8581428571428571, + 0.8581428571428571 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [ + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' score=0.86 | response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' score=0.86 | response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)", + "q='What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?' score=0.86 | response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)", + "q='Which teams need to be unblocked this week?' score=0.86 | response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)", + "q='What is the budget for Q3?' score=0.86 | response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)" + ], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.8581428571428571, + "holdout_score": 0.8581428571428571, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.8581428571428571, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.8581428571428571, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.45}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.45}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.45}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.78, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_7d022a054e67", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.8581, + "projected_score": 0.8581 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_87b6ab5abd3f.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_87b6ab5abd3f.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e511121 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_87b6ab5abd3f.json @@ -0,0 +1,334 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "87b6ab5abd3f", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.4295714285714286 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.4295714285714286, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature mus", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature mus", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature mus", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature mus", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature mus" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu", + "response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the 'r1' marker (temperature must be <= 0.5); response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperatu" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana" + }, + { + "query": "List the next steps for the delivery plan.", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to List the next steps for the delivery plan. banana" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana" + }, + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.6 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'blueberry', 'strawberry', 'OPT', 'banana' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana" + }, + { + "query": "List the next steps for the delivery plan.", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to List the next steps for the delivery plan. banana" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana" + }, + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.6 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.0}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.65}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=132), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.72, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_87b6ab5abd3f", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.6 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.4296 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_8ef4613380b1.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_8ef4613380b1.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8efc077 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_8ef4613380b1.json @@ -0,0 +1,292 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "8ef4613380b1", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714282, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "param_000_m00", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "model_params.temperature": { + "param_name": "model_params.temperature", + "old_value": 0.5, + "new_value": 0.05, + "reason": "Model param 'temperature': 0.5 → 0.05" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.5 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.05", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.6", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.3", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.4", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.2", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.15", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.25", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.65", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.2867, holdout=0.2867, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.2867, holdout=0.2867, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.2867, holdout=0.2867, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "gap": 0.0, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Model param 'temperature': 0.5 → 0.05" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.15, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_8ef4613380b1", + "confidence": "high", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_970f28b959d2.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_970f28b959d2.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ce12cc2 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_970f28b959d2.json @@ -0,0 +1,321 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "970f28b959d2", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.7152857142857143, + "baseline_score": 0.7152857142857143, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.7152857142857143, + 0.7152857142857143 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the 'r2' marker (temperature must be <= 0.3); response is missing the 'r3' marker (temperature must be <= 0.15)" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.7152857142857143, + "holdout_score": 0.7152857142857143, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.7152857142857143, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.7152857142857143, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.4}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.25}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.02}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.4}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.25}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.02}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.4}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.25}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.02}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.67, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_970f28b959d2", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.7153, + "projected_score": 0.7153 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_a279cf052e84.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_a279cf052e84.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..11fe848 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_a279cf052e84.json @@ -0,0 +1,385 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "a279cf052e84", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 1.0009999999999997, + 1.0009999999999997 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [ + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='Which teams need to be unblocked this week?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers", + "q='What is the budget for Q3?' score=1.00 | response contains all required markers" + ], + "what_failed": [], + "judge_insights": [ + "response contains all required markers" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Preserve strengths; tighten output contract and edge-case coverage." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "baseline_holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.5}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.5}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.8581428571428571, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.5724285714285714, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.55}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.7152857142857143, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.5}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.1}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 1.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.05}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=1.0010, holdout=1.0010, gap=-0.0000", + "fit_score": 1.0009999999999997, + "holdout_score": 1.001, + "gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'Judge', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Baseline already saturated at 1.0010. The fit metric is too easy (or the dataset is trivial) — prompt candidates cannot show improvement. Harden the metric (content overlap / must_include / judge rubric) and expand demos.", + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 1.08, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_a279cf052e84", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.15 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 1.001, + "projected_score": 1.001 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_a470866c4038.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_a470866c4038.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9276b92 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_a470866c4038.json @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "a470866c4038", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.2867142857142857, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 0 targeting: completeness — ensure answers cover all parts of the question. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 1 targeting: factual grounding — ensure answers are accurate and evidence-based. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 2 targeting: format compliance — ensure answers follow the requested structure. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.37, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "gepa_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_a470866c4038", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.2867, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_ad203babe878.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_ad203babe878.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..51234b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_ad203babe878.json @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "ad203babe878", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.14385714285714288, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Fit tips (from labelled demos)\n- Ground every answer ONLY in the provided snapshot; never invent budgets or stakeholders.\n- Always return non-empty JSON keys `content` and `next_action`.\n- Prefer concrete next actions (≥4 words) tied to unknowns/status.\n- When relevant, include these anchors naturally: banana.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "Who is accountable for the migration?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What are the open blockers for the release?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + }, + { + "query": "What was decided about the API contract?", + "response": "{\"response\": \"OPT, banana\"}" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "rewrite_000", + "source": "rewrite", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Full prompt rewrite at iteration 0 (3 pass(es): pass1_draft chars=452 style=slm, pass2_critique chars=326, pass3_revise chars=452). Analysed 6 failures (avg score 0.144) and 6 successes. Context: 1 rounds history, baseline=0.144, current=0.144.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.4, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "rewrite", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_ad203babe878", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.1439, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_af34d7408323.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_af34d7408323.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d274b53 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_af34d7408323.json @@ -0,0 +1,292 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "af34d7408323", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.001, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "param_000_m00", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.001, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "model_params.temperature": { + "param_name": "model_params.temperature", + "old_value": 0.7, + "new_value": 0.5, + "reason": "Model param 'temperature': 0.7 → 0.5" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.5 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.7 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.5", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.25", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.45", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.05", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.65", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.15", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.3", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.02", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "Model param 'temperature': 0.7 → 0.5" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.18, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_af34d7408323", + "confidence": "high", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.5 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_b9d95379dd2f.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_b9d95379dd2f.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5c46896 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_b9d95379dd2f.json @@ -0,0 +1,228 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "b9d95379dd2f", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.4295714285714286 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.4295714285714286, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.6", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.15", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.35", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.2", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.3", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.7", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.45", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.25", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.18, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_b9d95379dd2f", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.4296 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_c8cb38d88d83.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_c8cb38d88d83.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d335220 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_c8cb38d88d83.json @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "c8cb38d88d83", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.2867142857142857, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 0 targeting: completeness — ensure answers cover all parts of the question. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 1 targeting: factual grounding — ensure answers are accurate and evidence-based. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 2 targeting: format compliance — ensure answers follow the requested structure. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.42, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "gepa_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_c8cb38d88d83", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.2867, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_c8f5ec4447b2.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_c8f5ec4447b2.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cb29e79 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_c8f5ec4447b2.json @@ -0,0 +1,213 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "c8f5ec4447b2", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.001, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "gepa_000_0", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.001, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "system_prompt": { + "param_name": "system_prompt", + "old_value": "[31 chars]", + "new_value": "[138 chars]", + "reason": "System prompt revised (31 → 138 chars)" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 0 targeting: completeness — ensure answers cover all parts of the question. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 1 targeting: factual grounding — ensure answers are accurate and evidence-based. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 2 targeting: format compliance — ensure answers follow the requested structure. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "System prompt revised (31 → 138 chars)" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.37, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "gepa_like", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_c8f5ec4447b2", + "confidence": "high", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_d01b1f182694.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_d01b1f182694.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c4f7509 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_d01b1f182694.json @@ -0,0 +1,228 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "d01b1f182694", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.4295714285714286 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.4295714285714286, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.02", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.45", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.2", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.6", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.15", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.7", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.65", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.35", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.13, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_d01b1f182694", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.4296 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_d5d65ca1be6a.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_d5d65ca1be6a.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..abc4ed6 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_d5d65ca1be6a.json @@ -0,0 +1,240 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "d5d65ca1be6a", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.4295714285714286 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.4295714285714286, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.45", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.02", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.65", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.7", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.3", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.2", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.25", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.6", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m09", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.15", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.12, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_d5d65ca1be6a", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.4296 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_e2f6962c81a6.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_e2f6962c81a6.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ac54bf2 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_e2f6962c81a6.json @@ -0,0 +1,395 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "e2f6962c81a6", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, + "improved": true, + "score_history": [ + 0.001, + 0.14385714285714288 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": true, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token ", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.14 | response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token " + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an", + "response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal an" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "mipro_000_00", + "train_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.001, + "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.1429 + }, + "param_suggestions": { + "system_prompt": { + "param_name": "system_prompt", + "old_value": "[31 chars]", + "new_value": "[136 chars]", + "reason": "System prompt revised (31 → 136 chars)" + }, + "few_shot_examples": { + "param_name": "few_shot_examples", + "old_value": 0, + "new_value": 4, + "reason": "Few-shot examples changed (0 → 4)" + }, + "model_params.temperature": { + "param_name": "model_params.temperature", + "old_value": 0.7, + "new_value": 0.5, + "reason": "Model param 'temperature': 0.7 → 0.5" + } + }, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What happened at the steering committee?" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + } + ], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.5 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.7 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 0: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.5}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 1: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 2: instruction variant (len=136), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_03", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 3: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_04", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 4: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_05", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 5: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.5}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_06", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 6: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_07", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 7: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_08", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 8: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_09", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 9: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 12, + "trace_count": 60 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_10", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 10: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.5}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 13, + "trace_count": 65 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_11", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 11: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.35}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 14, + "trace_count": 70 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_12", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 12: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.2}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 15, + "trace_count": 75 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_13", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 13: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.6}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 16, + "trace_count": 80 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_14", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "MIPRO candidate 14: instruction variant (len=142), 4 few-shot examples, params={'temperature': 0.3}", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 17, + "trace_count": 85 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_00", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_01", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "mipro_000_02", + "source": "mipro_like", + "phase": "full_val", + "score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "generalization": { + "ok": true, + "reason": "Generalization OK: fit=0.1439, holdout=0.1439, gap=+0.0000", + "fit_score": 0.14385714285714288, + "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, + "gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "max_gap": 0.15 + }, + "dimensions": {}, + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "prompt_preview": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'Judge', 'OPT', 'guidance' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query." + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "System prompt revised (31 → 136 chars)", + "Few-shot examples changed (0 → 4)", + "Model param 'temperature': 0.7 → 0.5" + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.79, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "mipro_like", + "early_stop_reason": "completed all 1 optimize round(s) (max_trials=6)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_e2f6962c81a6", + "confidence": "high", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.5 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "canary", + "weight": 0.4, + "monitoring_hours": 12 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.1429, + "baseline_score": 0.001, + "projected_score": 0.1439 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_e53690ea44e7.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_e53690ea44e7.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..69e14a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_e53690ea44e7.json @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "e53690ea44e7", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.2867142857142857, + 0.2867142857142857 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.29 | response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token '" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);", + "response is missing the required marker token 'blueberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response is missing the required marker token 'kiwi' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer);" + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, + "generalization_gap": 0.0, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": {}, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_0", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 0 targeting: completeness — ensure answers cover all parts of the question. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_1", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 1 targeting: factual grounding — ensure answers are accurate and evidence-based. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "gepa_000_2", + "source": "gepa_like", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "GEPA mutation 2 targeting: format compliance — ensure answers follow the requested structure. Based on 8 feedback items.", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.41, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "gepa_like", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_e53690ea44e7", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.2867, + "projected_score": 0.2867 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_fd94ff3bc2e5.json b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_fd94ff3bc2e5.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..68a1652 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/fit_result_fd94ff3bc2e5.json @@ -0,0 +1,228 @@ +{ + "experiment_id": "fd94ff3bc2e5", + "agent": "marker_agent", + "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "absolute_improvement": 0.0, + "improved": false, + "score_history": [ + 0.4295714285714286, + 0.4295714285714286 + ], + "prompt_history": [ + { + "round_idx": 0, + "prompt_snapshot": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "score": 0.4295714285714286, + "dims": {}, + "accepted": false, + "what_worked": [], + "what_failed": [ + "q='When is the next release candidate?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='Who approved the scope change?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='List the next steps for the delivery plan.' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What follow-up is needed after the demo?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud", + "q='What happened at the steering committee?' expected≈\"## Judge guidance\\nThe ideal answer also includes the marker tokens 'strawberry', 'blueberry' and 'ki\" score=0.43 | response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (jud" + ], + "judge_insights": [ + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response ", + "response is missing the required marker token 'banana' (expected output contains 'OPT, banana'); response is missing the required marker token 'strawberry' (judge guidance lists it as part of the ideal answer); response " + ], + "next_focus": [ + "Address lowest-scoring failure modes without hardcoding those exact queries." + ], + "candidate_name": "", + "train_score": 0.4295714285714286, + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metadata": {} + } + ], + "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "baseline_holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, + "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, + "metric_deltas": { + "composite": 0.0 + }, + "param_suggestions": {}, + "best_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "baseline_config": { + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "user_template": null, + "few_shot_examples": [], + "output_contract": null, + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "rag_params": {}, + "tool_params": {}, + "model_choice": null, + "fallback_model": null, + "routing_config": {} + }, + "failure_clusters": [], + "trials": [ + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m00", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.2", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 3, + "trace_count": 15 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m01", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.5", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 4, + "trace_count": 20 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m02", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.2867142857142857, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.3", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 5, + "trace_count": 25 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m03", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.15", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 6, + "trace_count": 30 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m04", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.42957142857142855, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.0", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 7, + "trace_count": 35 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m05", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.14385714285714285, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.45", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 8, + "trace_count": 40 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m06", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.65", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 9, + "trace_count": 45 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m07", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.55", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 10, + "trace_count": 50 + }, + { + "round": 1, + "name": "param_000_m08", + "source": "param_search", + "phase": "minibatch", + "score": 0.001, + "dimensions": {}, + "mutation_notes": "Model param change (random): temperature=0.6", + "critique": "", + "resource_versions": 11, + "trace_count": 55 + } + ], + "suggestions": [ + "No configuration changes improved over the baseline." + ], + "duration_seconds": 0.13, + "applied": false, + "optimizer_name": "param_search", + "early_stop_reason": "no improvement for 1 round(s) (patience=1, monitor=best_score)", + "dataset_sizes": { + "train": 10, + "fit_val": 8, + "holdout": 2, + "test": 0 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "prompt_version": "v2_fit_fd94ff3bc2e5", + "confidence": "no_improvement", + "model_params": { + "temperature": 0.05 + }, + "deployment_recommendation": { + "rollout": "hold", + "weight": 0.0, + "monitoring_hours": 0 + }, + "monitoring": { + "metrics": [ + "composite" + ], + "rollback_threshold": -0.03, + "rollback_instructions": "If 'composite' drops below baseline, rollback to You are a helpful AI assistant... (previous version)." + }, + "expected_improvement": 0.0, + "baseline_score": 0.4296, + "projected_score": 0.4296 + } +} diff --git a/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/retrain_history.jsonl b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/retrain_history.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9661b4d --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/.fit/marker_agent/retrain_history.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +{"experiment_id": "6a68ffeb6239", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.001, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 1.41} +{"experiment_id": "28f28abcee98", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.35} +{"experiment_id": "2be78907a291", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.5} +{"experiment_id": "1ae10da0d0e0", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.37} +{"experiment_id": "ad203babe878", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.4} +{"experiment_id": "c8f5ec4447b2", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.001, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.37} +{"experiment_id": "c8cb38d88d83", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.42} +{"experiment_id": "12905a65554d", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.42} +{"experiment_id": "a470866c4038", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.37} +{"experiment_id": "5a5f2b0a2324", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.33} +{"experiment_id": "e53690ea44e7", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.2867142857142857, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.41} +{"experiment_id": "e2f6962c81a6", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.001, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.79} +{"experiment_id": "296d3b2b6cf1", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714282, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.62} +{"experiment_id": "87b6ab5abd3f", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.72} +{"experiment_id": "23c74d4ea257", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.5724285714285714, "absolute_improvement": 0.1428571428571428, "holdout_score": 0.5724285714285714, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.66} +{"experiment_id": "970f28b959d2", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.7152857142857143, "best_score": 0.7152857142857143, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.7152857142857143, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.67} +{"experiment_id": "7d022a054e67", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.8581428571428571, "best_score": 0.8581428571428571, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.8581428571428571, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.78} +{"experiment_id": "16acabe00699", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 1.001, "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.72} +{"experiment_id": "142c287799f8", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 1.001, "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.59} +{"experiment_id": "a279cf052e84", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 1.001, "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 1.08} +{"experiment_id": "5e91ff17f6cc", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 1.0009999999999997, "best_score": 1.0009999999999997, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 1.001, "generalization_gap": -2.220446049250313e-16, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.76} +{"experiment_id": "7af1cc2a1511", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.001, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.15} +{"experiment_id": "736d05749772", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.19} +{"experiment_id": "3d1f73e32b77", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.17} +{"experiment_id": "46c20a9af339", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.12} +{"experiment_id": "58f5a7c0ef7c", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.11} +{"experiment_id": "af34d7408323", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.001, "best_score": 0.14385714285714288, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714288, "holdout_score": 0.14385714285714285, "generalization_gap": 2.7755575615628914e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.18} +{"experiment_id": "8ef4613380b1", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.14385714285714288, "best_score": 0.2867142857142857, "absolute_improvement": 0.14285714285714282, "holdout_score": 0.2867142857142857, "generalization_gap": 0.0, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.15} +{"experiment_id": "d01b1f182694", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.13} +{"experiment_id": "538677bc709e", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.13} +{"experiment_id": "fd94ff3bc2e5", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.13} +{"experiment_id": "b9d95379dd2f", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.18} +{"experiment_id": "d5d65ca1be6a", "agent": "marker_agent", "baseline_score": 0.4295714285714286, "best_score": 0.4295714285714286, "absolute_improvement": 0.0, "holdout_score": 0.42957142857142855, "generalization_gap": 5.551115123125783e-17, "n_epochs": 1, "duration_seconds": 0.12} diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/config.json b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a206226 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/config.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?" + }, + { + "query": "What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?", + "response": "BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?" + }, + { + "query": "Who approved the scope change?", + "response": "BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?" + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/evaluation_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/evaluation_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..137067a --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/evaluation_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +[ + { + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "dataset_name": "inline", + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.14285714285714288, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "num_examples": 4, + "pass_rate": 0.0, + "metadata": {}, + "example_results": [ + { + "example_id": "marker_016", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?\n\nExample 2\nQ: What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\nA: BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\n\nExample 3\nQ: Who approved the scope change?\nA: BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 1, + "difficulty": 1 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.14285714285714288, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.16948600000432634, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_017", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to Which teams need to be unblocked this week? banana", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?\n\nExample 2\nQ: What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\nA: BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\n\nExample 3\nQ: Who approved the scope change?\nA: BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 1, + "difficulty": 1 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.14285714285714288, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.10843399991244951, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_018", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?\n\nExample 2\nQ: What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\nA: BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\n\nExample 3\nQ: Who approved the scope change?\nA: BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 1, + "difficulty": 1 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.14285714285714288, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.09667599988461006, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_019", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to What is the current status of the project? banana", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: BASE: answer to What is the budget for Q3?\n\nExample 2\nQ: What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\nA: BASE: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting?\n\nExample 3\nQ: Who approved the scope change?\nA: BASE: answer to Who approved the scope change?\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: BASE: answer to When is the next release candidate?", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 1, + "difficulty": 1 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.14285714285714288, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.10697800007619662, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + } + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/fit_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/fit_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c68b31f --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/fit_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,249 @@ +{ + "params": { + "epochs": 10, + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "loss": "quality_loss", + "train_size": 10, + "val_size": 6, + "optimize": { + "search_space": { + "optimize_system_prompt": false, + "optimize_user_template": false, + "optimize_few_shot": true, + "optimize_model_params": false, + "optimize_rag_params": false, + "optimize_tool_params": false, + "optimize_model_choice": false, + "model_param_space": { + "temperature": [ + 0.0, + 0.1, + 0.2, + 0.4, + 0.7 + ], + "top_p": [ + 0.7, + 0.9, + 1.0 + ], + "max_tokens": [ + 800, + 1200, + 2000 + ] + }, + "rag_param_space": {}, + "tool_param_space": {}, + "model_choices": [], + "fallback_models": [], + "routing_weight_space": {}, + "max_few_shot_examples": 5, + "few_shot_selection_strategy": "diversity_weighted", + "search_method": "random", + "optimize_nodes": [], + "node_match": null + }, + "optimizer": "few_shot_bootstrap", + "max_trials": 6 + } + }, + "epoch": [ + -1, + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "history": { + "banana": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "r1": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.14285714285714285 + ], + "exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.857142857142857 + ], + "val_banana": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_r1": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.14285714285714288 + ], + "val_exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.8571428571428571 + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/metadata.json b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/metadata.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..937638b --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/few_shot_bootstrap/metadata.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "agent_class": "examples.keras_optimize_showcase.agent.MarkerAgent", + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "agent_version": "1.0.0", + "dataset_name": "marker_fake", + "dataset_size": 20, + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "loss": "quality_loss" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/config.json b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..328a48a --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/config.json @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +{ + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "few_shot_examples": [] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/evaluation_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/evaluation_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..86ea708 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/evaluation_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +[ + { + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "dataset_name": "inline", + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.28571428571428575, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "num_examples": 4, + "pass_rate": 0.0, + "metadata": {}, + "example_results": [ + { + "example_id": "marker_016", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana strawberry", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 2, + "difficulty": 4 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.28571428571428575, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.20288800010348496, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_017", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to Which teams need to be unblocked this week? banana strawberry", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 2, + "difficulty": 4 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.28571428571428575, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.1554619998387352, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_018", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 2, + "difficulty": 4 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.28571428571428575, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.14165600009619084, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_019", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the current status of the project? banana strawberry", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'banana', 'strawberry', 'Judge', 'OPT' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "temperature": 0.7, + "temp_ok": false, + "temp_rungs": 0, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 2, + "difficulty": 4 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 0.0, + "r1": 0.0, + "r2": 0.0, + "r3": 0.0, + "quality": 0.28571428571428575, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.13400100010585447, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + } + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/fit_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/fit_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1b3f96a --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/fit_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,272 @@ +{ + "params": { + "epochs": 10, + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "loss": "quality_loss", + "train_size": 10, + "val_size": 6, + "optimize": { + "search_space": { + "optimize_system_prompt": true, + "optimize_user_template": false, + "optimize_few_shot": false, + "optimize_model_params": false, + "optimize_rag_params": false, + "optimize_tool_params": false, + "optimize_model_choice": false, + "model_param_space": { + "temperature": [ + 0.0, + 0.1, + 0.2, + 0.4, + 0.7 + ], + "top_p": [ + 0.7, + 0.9, + 1.0 + ], + "max_tokens": [ + 800, + 1200, + 2000 + ] + }, + "rag_param_space": {}, + "tool_param_space": {}, + "model_choices": [], + "fallback_models": [], + "routing_weight_space": {}, + "max_few_shot_examples": 5, + "few_shot_selection_strategy": "diversity_weighted", + "search_method": "random", + "optimize_nodes": [], + "node_match": null + }, + "optimizer": "gepa_like", + "max_trials": 6 + } + }, + "epoch": [ + -1, + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "history": { + "banana": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "r1": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.2857142857142857, + 0.2857142857142857, + 0.2857142857142857, + 0.2857142857142857, + 0.2857142857142857 + ], + "exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143 + ], + "val_banana": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_r1": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.28571428571428575, + 0.28571428571428575, + 0.28571428571428575, + 0.28571428571428575, + 0.28571428571428575 + ], + "val_exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.7142857142857143 + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/metadata.json b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/metadata.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..937638b --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/gepa_like/metadata.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "agent_class": "examples.keras_optimize_showcase.agent.MarkerAgent", + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "agent_version": "1.0.0", + "dataset_name": "marker_fake", + "dataset_size": 20, + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "loss": "quality_loss" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/config.json b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e737c6a --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/config.json @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +{ + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.", + "few_shot_examples": [ + { + "query": "What happened at the steering committee?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What follow-up is needed after the demo?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "What is the budget for Q3?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry" + }, + { + "query": "When is the next release candidate?", + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry" + } + ], + "temperature": 0.15 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/evaluation_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/evaluation_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f0bc8a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/evaluation_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +[ + { + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "dataset_name": "inline", + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 1.0, + "kiwi": 1.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 1.0, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "num_examples": 4, + "pass_rate": 1.0, + "metadata": {}, + "example_results": [ + { + "example_id": "marker_016", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? banana strawberry blueberry kiwi r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What happened at the steering committee?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 2\nQ: What follow-up is needed after the demo?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 3\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry", + "temperature": 0.15, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": true, + "kiwi_ok": true, + "n_satisfied": 7, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 1.0, + "kiwi": 1.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 1.0, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.2729759999056114, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_017", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to Which teams need to be unblocked this week? banana strawberry blueberry kiwi r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What happened at the steering committee?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 2\nQ: What follow-up is needed after the demo?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 3\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry", + "temperature": 0.15, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": true, + "kiwi_ok": true, + "n_satisfied": 7, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 1.0, + "kiwi": 1.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 1.0, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.16014500010896882, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_018", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry kiwi r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What happened at the steering committee?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 2\nQ: What follow-up is needed after the demo?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 3\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry", + "temperature": 0.15, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": true, + "kiwi_ok": true, + "n_satisfied": 7, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 1.0, + "kiwi": 1.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 1.0, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.16184500009330804, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_019", + "prediction": { + "response": "OPT: answer to What is the current status of the project? banana strawberry blueberry kiwi r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant. Always include 'OPT', 'banana', 'kiwi', 'Judge' in your answer, exactly as written, for every query.\n\n## Few-shot examples\n\nExample 1\nQ: What happened at the steering committee?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What happened at the steering committee? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 2\nQ: What follow-up is needed after the demo?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What follow-up is needed after the demo? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 3\nQ: What is the budget for Q3?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? banana strawberry blueberry\n\nExample 4\nQ: When is the next release candidate?\nA: PARTIAL: answer to When is the next release candidate? banana strawberry blueberry", + "temperature": 0.15, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": true, + "strawberry_ok": true, + "blueberry_ok": true, + "kiwi_ok": true, + "n_satisfied": 7, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 1.0, + "strawberry": 1.0, + "blueberry": 1.0, + "kiwi": 1.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 1.0, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.1364820000162581, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + } + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/fit_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/fit_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..85d7ac9 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/fit_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,365 @@ +{ + "params": { + "epochs": 10, + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "loss": "quality_loss", + "train_size": 10, + "val_size": 6, + "optimize": { + "search_space": { + "optimize_system_prompt": true, + "optimize_user_template": false, + "optimize_few_shot": true, + "optimize_model_params": true, + "optimize_rag_params": false, + "optimize_tool_params": false, + "optimize_model_choice": false, + "model_param_space": { + "temperature": [ + 0.7, + 0.65, + 0.6, + 0.55, + 0.5, + 0.45, + 0.4, + 0.35, + 0.3, + 0.25, + 0.2, + 0.15, + 0.1, + 0.05, + 0.02, + 0.0 + ] + }, + "rag_param_space": {}, + "tool_param_space": {}, + "model_choices": [], + "fallback_models": [], + "routing_weight_space": {}, + "max_few_shot_examples": 5, + "few_shot_selection_strategy": "diversity_weighted", + "search_method": "random", + "optimize_nodes": [], + "node_match": null + }, + "optimizer": "mipro_like", + "max_trials": 6 + } + }, + "epoch": [ + -1, + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 5, + 6, + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "history": { + "banana": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "r1": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.2857142857142857, + 0.4285714285714287, + 0.5714285714285714, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.8571428571428574, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.4285714285714285, + 0.28571428571428564, + 0.1428571428571428, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_banana": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_r1": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.28571428571428575, + 0.42857142857142866, + 0.5714285714285715, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.8571428571428573, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.42857142857142844, + 0.28571428571428564, + 0.1428571428571428, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/metadata.json b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/metadata.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..937638b --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/mipro_like/metadata.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "agent_class": "examples.keras_optimize_showcase.agent.MarkerAgent", + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "agent_version": "1.0.0", + "dataset_name": "marker_fake", + "dataset_size": 20, + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "loss": "quality_loss" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/config.json b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ec743a0 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/config.json @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +{ + "system_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "few_shot_examples": [], + "temperature": 0.05 +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/evaluation_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/evaluation_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4ba0800 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/evaluation_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +[ + { + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "dataset_name": "inline", + "scores": { + "banana": 0.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 0.42857142857142866, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "num_examples": 4, + "pass_rate": 0.0, + "metadata": {}, + "example_results": [ + { + "example_id": "marker_016", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What did the customer ask for in the last meeting? r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "temperature": 0.05, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": false, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 3, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 0.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 0.42857142857142866, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.20074999997632403, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_017", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to Which teams need to be unblocked this week? r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "temperature": 0.05, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": false, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 3, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 0.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 0.42857142857142866, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.21136499981366796, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_018", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the budget for Q3? r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "temperature": 0.05, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": false, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 3, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 0.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 0.42857142857142866, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.1616590000139695, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + }, + { + "example_id": "marker_019", + "prediction": { + "response": "PARTIAL: answer to What is the current status of the project? r1 r2 r3", + "used_prompt": "You are a helpful AI assistant.", + "temperature": 0.05, + "temp_ok": true, + "temp_rungs": 3, + "banana_ok": false, + "strawberry_ok": false, + "blueberry_ok": false, + "kiwi_ok": false, + "n_satisfied": 3, + "difficulty": 7 + }, + "scores": { + "banana": 0.0, + "strawberry": 0.0, + "blueberry": 0.0, + "kiwi": 0.0, + "temp_ok": 1.0, + "r1": 1.0, + "r2": 1.0, + "r3": 1.0, + "quality": 0.42857142857142866, + "exact_key_match": 1.0 + }, + "duration_ms": 0.19959599990215793, + "error": null, + "metadata": {} + } + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/fit_history.json b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/fit_history.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..330833d --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/fit_history.json @@ -0,0 +1,296 @@ +{ + "params": { + "epochs": 10, + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "loss": "quality_loss", + "train_size": 10, + "val_size": 6, + "optimize": { + "search_space": { + "optimize_system_prompt": false, + "optimize_user_template": false, + "optimize_few_shot": false, + "optimize_model_params": true, + "optimize_rag_params": false, + "optimize_tool_params": false, + "optimize_model_choice": false, + "model_param_space": { + "temperature": [ + 0.7, + 0.65, + 0.6, + 0.55, + 0.5, + 0.45, + 0.4, + 0.35, + 0.3, + 0.25, + 0.2, + 0.15, + 0.1, + 0.05, + 0.02, + 0.0 + ] + }, + "rag_param_space": {}, + "tool_param_space": {}, + "model_choices": [], + "fallback_models": [], + "routing_weight_space": {}, + "max_few_shot_examples": 5, + "few_shot_selection_strategy": "diversity_weighted", + "search_method": "random", + "optimize_nodes": [], + "node_match": null + }, + "optimizer": "param_search", + "max_trials": 6 + } + }, + "epoch": [ + -1, + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "history": { + "banana": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "r1": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714285, + 0.2857142857142857, + 0.4285714285714287, + 0.4285714285714287, + 0.4285714285714287, + 0.4285714285714287, + 0.4285714285714287 + ], + "exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.857142857142857, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713 + ], + "val_banana": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_strawberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_blueberry": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_kiwi": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "val_temp_ok": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_r1": [ + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_r2": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_r3": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_quality": [ + 0.0, + 0.14285714285714288, + 0.28571428571428575, + 0.42857142857142866, + 0.42857142857142866, + 0.42857142857142866, + 0.42857142857142866, + 0.42857142857142866 + ], + "val_exact_key_match": [ + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0, + 1.0 + ], + "val_loss": [ + 1.0, + 0.8571428571428571, + 0.7142857142857143, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713, + 0.5714285714285713 + ] + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/metadata.json b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/metadata.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..937638b --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/param_search/metadata.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "agent_class": "examples.keras_optimize_showcase.agent.MarkerAgent", + "agent_name": "marker_agent", + "agent_version": "1.0.0", + "dataset_name": "marker_fake", + "dataset_size": 20, + "metrics": [ + "banana", + "strawberry", + "blueberry", + "kiwi", + "temp_ok", + "r1", + "r2", + "r3", + "quality", + "exact_key_match" + ], + "optimizer": "PromptFitterBridge", + "loss": "quality_loss" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/optimization_results/showcase/reports/fit_few_shot_bootstrap.html b/optimization_results/showcase/reports/fit_few_shot_bootstrap.html new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4850d90 --- /dev/null +++ b/optimization_results/showcase/reports/fit_few_shot_bootstrap.html @@ -0,0 +1,332 @@ + + +
+ + +